Four Years & Two Million Dollars Later, Lessons from a Failed Startup

Bassel Idriss, Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer — Formidable Microfactory

If you’re thinking of starting your own business because you’re after the ‘glorious’ end and not the journey getting there, don’t bother! … If you’re not tenaciously persistent; get excited by seemingly insurmountable challenges; easily swayed or care too much about what others think and say, don’t bother! … If you think failing will be the ‘end of you’, also, don’t bother!

Bassel Idriss, Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer — Formidable Microfactory
Bassel Idriss, Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer — Formidable Microfactory

At Generics, we set out to solve for poor fitting, uncomfortable earphones. We mak(d)e custom eartips to the shape and size of individual ears through an App, photogrammetry and 3D Printing. I failed to raise cash fast enough to scale. Here are some of the lessons I learned along the way.

Make sure you’re really solving a problem, not a nuisance.

A solution to a ‘problem’ or pain-point is a must-have. Conversely, a solution to a ‘nuisance’ is a nice-to-have. You’re looking to deliver a pain-killer, not a vitamin! Solving for a problem will dramatically improve your chances of success. The added bonus of solving for a big, difficult problem is a higher barrier-to-entry and fewer competitors. If you don’t know how big the problem you’re solving is, find out quick. Ask ‘potential’ customers and consumers, not family and friends, whether they will go out of their way and pay for your product. @Generics, we knew the problem was prevalent, however, today, judge it was more nuisance vs. pain-point for most people. Be brutally honest with yourself.

Deliver the simplest solution to the problem.

In startup jargon, this is the minimum-viable-product (MVP). Don’t fall into the trap of ‘just one more feature to make product great’. Despite all your efforts to make your first product perfect, it will not be! Don’t waste time and resources trying to achieve the impossible. Just make sure your product provides value to users. Develop the ‘perfect’ solution later, when you better understand what your users want and have more resources. @Generics, we first made fully functional earphones. They had to fit well, feel comfortable, sound great, look beautiful, exude minimalism, have a rotating bezel, a removable ‘custom initials cap’, strong cable, cost less than $45… We should have focused only on making custom great fitting eartips for select earphone models, dropped everything else, we would have saved time and money. Be pragmatic, keep it simple.

Start fast, test faster and pivot faster still.

I took too long to decide I am starting my own business. Once I did, spent too much time developing an intricate business model that later proved worthless. Took too much time figuring out how to ‘sell’ my PowerPoint to investors. Took too long to raise money. Took too long to develop the MVP. To go-to-market. Almost 3 years! To get ‘paying’ consumers feedback. Took too long to make our first pivot, a little faster but still slow for our second pivot, even though I knew 73% of startups pivot (EPFL University). At the time, each of these felt really important and merited I spend ample time to get right, in hindsight, while important, they simply took too long. I should have skipped or completed much faster applying Pareto’s law. Don’t waste time, once your mind is made up, take the plunge, go all out, focus on the big things and correct course when you know you’re heading the wrong way.

Develop and test your ‘go-to-market’ as you build product.

Developing your commercial plan after you’re done building product is too late! Testing various go-to-market models will yield priceless learnings that will impact and shape your product development. Tweaking product to reflect learnings after you’ve locked development will waste time and money. Early results will also flush out ‘red flags’. You would rather find out quick there is no demand to what you’re building so you tweak or abandon project ahead of wasting months and hundreds of thousands in development. Don’t fear getting feedback on a ‘half-cooked’ product. Call it ‘beta’ and sell it at a reduced price if you must. Customers and consumers who don’t like it will not hold a grudge against you. When developing your ‘go-to-market’ don’t just think brand equity and key benefit communication. Think of your audience, the customers and consumers who are struggling most with the problem you set out to solve. Think ‘How’ and ‘When’ you want to reach them. @Generics, our audience were daily earphone users who listen to music while working out. We wanted to reach them during their exercise regiment as they experience their pain-point. Test different channels, figure out what works best for you and optimise for cost. Leverage digital, like SEM and social media, test others. Gabriel Weinberg & Justin Mares Traction is a great resource to help set your testing framework and inspire ideas. Prove product/ market fit.

Understand the skill-set required to build your product and commercial plan, only hire for that.

Make sure you have the ‘right’ people working your project. ‘Right’ are those with relevant expertise and/ or experience, those who are persistent and will keep at it. Only hire individuals working on your core solution. Make sure to focus their efforts on solving for and delivering your core product. Prioritise and make a deliberate choice to shed anything not fundamental to your core product. This will give you the best chance at successfully delivering solution, fast, without overhead costs spiraling out of control. Tell ‘under-performers’ what they are doing wrong, give them weeks to correct, otherwise, they are not the right fit. You will hesitate to let people go every time you think of the immense effort and time you must re-invest into searching, interviewing, on-boarding new team members. Time you could spend developing product and go-to-market. It remains the right thing to do. Keeping under-performing individuals will impact you more negatively vs. investing time to find the right hires. @Generics, it took me a while to figure out the required skill-set, didn’t find the right talent in the region, ended up developing product without a fully qualified team and only managed to do so due to the team’s intelligence, sheer will and extraordinary effort. Nonetheless, it came at a price! Sapped our energy and took way too long to develop. Another mistake was to front-hire, I expected a deluge of orders that never came. Hire for big impact, make sure individuals have the skills and attitude to succeed, hire slow and keep team focused on solving for core product.

Build traction. Build traction. Build traction.

Sell your product to every relevant customer and consumer you meet. Start selling day one, it’s never too early and it’s Ok if you start small! Apart from collecting learnings, it is imperative you build ‘sales-history’ or traction. Traction is like magic! With it everything is, at least, x100 times easier. Motivating yourself, your team and collaborators. Negotiating with suppliers, engaging your community and media. It is also pivotal for investor discussions. A growing sales trend over a sustained period proves customers and consumers want what you built. It is your single, strongest data point with potential investors. Growth hacking will help you get there. Apart from being one of startup world’s biggest buzzwords, growth hacking is combining programming and marketing know-how to get more and more people paying for and using your product. They need to become aware your solution exists, they need to feel compelled to try it and keep coming back for more. Sean Ellis & Morgan Brown’s Hacking Growth is an excellent resource to get started. @Generics, we held back on sharing product until we thought it was ‘perfect’. We also spent a lot of time developing equity, brand character and voice, tweaking our ‘look and feel’, however, kept it locked behind closed doors, didn’t test various channels, too afraid to reach out to our audience ahead of completing our product ‘masterpiece’. We wasted learning and optimisation opportunities. We disproportionately invested in ‘perfecting’ product and started building traction too little too late, when we had run out of money. Without traction our quest to raise more money and investor discussions were painful. Build traction.

Check your bias.

Yes you must be data-driven and yes you should ‘marry’ this with gut feel. However, what you think is right because of everything you learned throughout your career might not be right for your current challenge. @Generics, we developed a product to sell consumers. It was always very clear, we are a direct-to-consumer proposition, that’s what I have always done throughout my career. I am a Business-to-Consumer model guy. I overlooked the amount of resources it takes to build awareness, trial and equity (unless you’re lucky and your product goes viral). Throughout my career I was supported by marketing powerhouses, there was always ‘minimal’ support; in startup world there is no ‘minimal support’ at your disposal. We should have focused first on selling to earphone manufacturers (Business-to-Business) vs. trying to sell consumers directly. Take stock, give your innate reaction another thought, (re)assess what others in your space are doing before you decide on your course of action.

Surround yourself with the right advisers, they make a world of a difference.

What is a ‘right’ adviser? Individuals that bring something tangible and fast to the table. Who are ‘advisers’? Mentors, board members, consultants etc. You are not looking for ‘head-nodders’, they will just massage your ego. You also want to avoid constant challengers, they will tire you. You want people who have expertise in a certain area you need, at a specific stage of development, action-oriented and will say it like it is. Leverage advisers to solve a clear imminent challenge, such as introducing you to your first customers, retailers, partners, investors. Give you fast access to legislators and influencers. They will remove ‘roadblocks’. Once up and running, look for more strategic, less operational advisers that can help you make the right decisions long term. Be mindful your requirements will change at various stages of development, change advisers accordingly.

When it’s time for investors, make sure you understand their mindset and needs.

Move East or West if you’re building a hardware startup. I judge it’s ‘almost’ impossible to succeed building hardware in the Middle East today. Two key reasons, you will struggle to find (i) individuals with manufacturing expertise and (ii) the right investors. ‘Regional’ investors are not interested in and lack experience with hardware development and startups. The challenges, potential pitfalls and myths of building hardware are ‘top of mind’: takes more money and longer to develop, a mistake more costly vs. software, constricted Arab borders make distribution very difficult. And they are spoiled for choice behind the region’s explosive software startups growth. The good news is these same investors are hungry for software startups, have way more experience working with them. Many have developed best-in-class models for assessing a startup’s potential and providing the required support. Do your homework, research potential investors prior to engaging them, understand their mandate, startup portfolio, affinities and selection criteria. There is money out there for ‘software’ startups, you can get it.

Brace yourself for an emotional roller coaster ride (with a physical toll).

A snippet from my ride: Happiness at locking first round of funding… excitement at bringing team together… thrill of first working prototype… despair digesting magnitude of challenge… anguish at delayed production… delight at mass production completion… some sleepless nights… joy at beating crowdfunding target… gratification with first units shipped… elation and despair reflecting on early consumer feedback… anxiety with pivot… misery of new investor rejections… pride with 3rd party product endorsements… a few more grey hairs… heartache with more investor rejections… a minor slipped disc… distress with further investor rejections, as we run out of cash, as sales slow down to a trickle and higher cholesterol levels. The physical toll might be a consequence of me starting my entrepreneurial journey at 40, I am almost sure though stress played a co-starring role. My investors, friends and more importantly family were supportive, without them, I would not have kept on. Reach out to your confidants for emotional support when you need it.

I also made a few promises to myself early on that helped keep me steadfast, here are a few:

  • I promised myself to stay upbeat, optimistic and believe in what I am doing in the face of setbacks. Some days were really tough, I was tested on multiple occasions. Externally… I kept my promise, internally… I doubted myself on occasion, but kept going for my team, investors and self
  • I promised myself to stop if I am not learning. I am a better business person today vs. 2015
  • I promised myself I would not compromise my family’s pre-entrepreneurship ‘standard of living’. I slipped here, I intend to make it up over the next few years
  • I promised myself (and partner) to cap my losses at two thirds of my savings. Knowing when to call it a day is mandatory. I delivered.

I didn’t deliver on my goal: a successful, thriving business. Despite this failure, I loved and embraced the journey. I would do many things differently, however, after a recharge, I would do it all over again!

Bassel Idriss is the Co-Founder & Chief Executive Officer — Formidable Microfactory

 

Charles Rapulu Udoh

Charles Rapulu Udoh is a Lagos-based Lawyer with special focus on Business Law, Intellectual Property Rights, Entertainment and Technology Law. He is also an award-winning writer. Working for notable organizations so far has exposed him to some of industry best practices in business, finance strategies, law, dispute resolution, and data analytics both in Nigeria and across the world

6 Reasons Every Startup Must Read Daily

Startups are newly founded companies that are just beginning to develop, just as toddlers need six classes of food to develop strong immune systems so do startups with reading as one of the nutrients required for their necessary growth.

Reading is always attributed to students and academia but rarely attributed to startups. Reading is referred to as one of the basic tools of success in life because it increases your confidence and makes you fit for the tasks ahead. An average startup needs to read at least once a week to survive challenges of life.

The importance of reading cannot be overemphasized especially for the
growth of startups; reading gives startups the wings to fly and necessary techniques to have a soft landing.

An average startup needs to read at least once a week to survive challenges of life.

Often, as easy as reading sounds, it is one of the most difficult tasks to carry out but it becomes quite easy when the reasons for reading are valid and the reasons include:

  1. Constant learning
  2. New Ideas
  3. Business Skills
  4. Global Competition
  5. Inspiration and Motivation
  6. Building Relationships

Constant Learning

Learning is a daily activity that can be achieved through reading. Reading frequently enables startups to learn how to solve problems and think critically in the most dynamic way. Learning via reading helps startups to learn from the experience of others most especially experiences from businesses which have grown from being startups to successful business empires. Reading gives startups blueprints of businesses they aspire to go into.

New Ideas

Reading helps to connect more ideas on what you already know to some ideas on your mind to give birth (bring to reality) new products or services. Reading helps to validate most ideas of startups; many ideas startups develop aside from some original seed ideas give startups abilities to climb the ladder of success and growth speedily. 

Business Skills

The ability for startups to open their gates to business is good; the acquiring of business skills and improvement of previous business skills are more important and they can mostly be gotten through reading. The acquisition of these skills increase the longevity of startups.

Global Competition

Given that startups start operating from their local markets, most startups have the vision to operate in the global market and become global competitors.

Startups can do investigations about the feasibility of conquering a foreign market without going over themselves.  

Inspiration and Motivation

Starting and running startups daily is not a walk in the park. The trials, difficulties, and mistakes a startup goes through are huge; only a startup that reads daily can overcome.

Reading gives you an insight into what other startups went through and what they are still going through. It inspires startups to wield through the storm and motivates them to do exploits even with their present challenges.

Building Relationships

 Hard work, dedication and long hours are good traits in startups but the ability for startups to build and sustain relationships with different human resources that contribute positively to them is key for the survival of any business and this can be achieved through reading.

Reading is wealth. No doubt, different challenges of business could be solved through reading. Constant reading keeps startups steps away from liquidation.

See also: 7 Reasons Africa Is A Fertile Ground For Startups
Chisom Okeke

Chisom Okeke, popularly known as “Somly” is a graduate of Accounting from the University of Benin, Benin City. She is a phenomenal writer and an “Agripreneur” whose focus is to change the narrative of the agricultural sector by providing timely agricultural information and opportunities available in the agricultural sector. She is also a virtual assistant and the anchor of Somly Writes. You can connect with her via Social Media, Facebook – Okeke Chisom; Instagram – okeke_somly; Twitter – somly

Discover 5 Obvious Reasons Startups Fail In Africa

The rate at which startups are built in Africa is amazing, especially startups that are innovative or startups that meet a dire need. In recent times, Africa has been blessed with great startups, most of which are successful and have created lots of opportunities not only for its population but also added to the economic growth of the continent.

Some successful startups which are making waves and waxing stronger daily include Jumia, Dropfi, Saya, Ushahidi amongst a host of others.

Just as startups spring up daily, the rate at which they disappear from the face of the earth is quite alarming. According to Statistics brain, 25% of startups fail after the first year, 36% fail after the second year, 44% fail after the third year while 78% of startups disappear after year 10.

One may begin to wonder the reasons startups fail so that other startups can avoid them in order to exist longer than the tenth year. Every startup that fails has a different reason why it went under but there are major reasons why startups keep failing and they include:

. Product

.Planning

.Marketing

.Followup capital

.Money

Product

The idea or a physical product of a startup is one factor that keeps entrepreneurs highly optimistic and enthusiastic, so much that they fail to do the needful concerning their proposed product. Granted that this product has passed all theoretical tests but what about realistic tests?


Often times, startups develop products for themselves instead of the market.

Most startups fail to do a thorough market survey about a potential product. They fail to check if the product is friendly if the market is ready for this product, they also fail to take into cognizance the voice of their potential customers and go ahead to launch products that are not ready.

Planning

The planning of a business can be seen as the organizing or designing of a business framework in other to achieve great success and this includes the setting of goals, schedules, task, and objectives.
A startup without detailed planning is qualified as a failed candidate. For a startup to succeed, the appropriate structure needs to be put in place.

In Africa, some entrepreneurs start up a business with the idea of employing staffs and checking the books at a given time.
Knowing when to cut your losses and reroute your efforts is highly important and it can only be done when adequate planning has been made.

Marketing

Most startups bask in the euphoria of the awesomeness of their product that they fail to do adequate marketing of their product/services expecting the market to grant them a soft landing.
Marketing in the life of startups cannot be overemphasized and the earlier startups come to terms with it the better for them. No matter how old a startup is, marketing is needed to remind your customers of the importance of using your products/services.

Follow-on funding

Follow-on funds are funds that are used at the later stage of a business or company. Startups make provision for seed funds but fail to make provision for follow-on funds.
Many startups need continual financing for periods longer than they predicted as the rate of launching out is done at a loss and funds are needed to cover the operating cost of the startup to prevent going under.

Money

One of the cogent reasons for the failure of startups is money. Most entrepreneurs are so comfortable with their new status that they relax and go overboard with expenses forgetting that a startup is one that needs a constant influx of money.
They tend to employ staffs that are not needed, rent a bigger space and live a life worthy of a CEO.

Gary Vaynerchuk explained in his book of how he spent money that was important in solving his needs and never thought of acquiring the latest car model even when his business was raking in millions of Dollars, he never saw himself as a millionaire and this is the kind of attitude that most African entrepreneurs should emulate.

As much as we try to be optimistic in our daily dealings especially when starting out in business, the success of a startup rests on the shoulders of knowledge of what will and what will not seek the ship of a startup.

Related: 7 Reasons Africa Is A Fertile Ground For Startups

Okeke Chisom

Chisom Okeke, popularly known as “Somly” is a graduate of Accounting from the University of Benin, Benin City. She is a phenomenal writer and an “Agripreneur” whose focus is to change the narrative of the agricultural sector by providing timely agricultural information and opportunities available in the agricultural sector. She is also a virtual assistant and the anchor of Somly Writes. You can connect with her via Social Media, Facebook – Okeke Chisom; Instagram – okeke_somly; Twitter – somly